Top 12 Best Cigar Ashtrays Reviewed in 2019

by CigarCigar
cigar in a stylish ashtray

Cigar ashtrays are one of the must-have accessories that many people overlook. If you are using a cigarette ashtray you are doing not only yourself but the entire cigar community a disservice! Cigars exude class and sophistication so do yourself a favor and find an ashtray that fits your style.

Cigar accessories say a lot about who you are as a person so in the following post the team at Cigar Cigar Info review and compare the best cigar ashtrays on the market.

Best Cigar Ashtrays Available Online

$20.99
in stock
2 new from $20.99
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$21.49
in stock
2 new from $19.99
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$38.50
in stock
3 new from $38.50
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$12.99
in stock
1 new from $12.99
Amazon.com
Free shipping
out of stock
Amazon.com
$45.00
in stock
3 new from $45.00
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$22.47
$37.40
in stock
1 new from $22.47
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$30.00
in stock
1 new from $30.00
Amazon.com
$13.99
in stock
1 new from $13.99
1 used from $13.48
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$21.99
in stock
1 new from $21.99
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$14.99
$25.00
in stock
1 new from $14.99
Amazon.com
Free shipping
$57.00
in stock
5 new from $49.90
Amazon.com
Free shipping
Last updated on November 8, 2019 10:04 am

1. Comfify Cast Iron Hand Antique Ashtray

Comfify Cast Iron Hand Antique Ashtray

$20.99  in stock
2 new from $20.99
Free shipping
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • A GREAT ADDITION FOR YOUR CIGAR ACCESSORIES COLLECTION - You can use the cigar ashtray for your cabin or home décor - it looks great with a cigar or without one. Our cast iron ashtrays are attractive with a rustic look that will make your home look more beautiful.
  • GREAT CIGAR GIFT IDEA FOR A MAN IN YOUR LIFE - This cast iron ashtray is a great gift idea for someone you care about, whether they smoke or not. This is a great decorative piece for your "man cave".
  • NOT JUST A METAL ASHTRAY - This item is a décor piece. A metal ashtray can be used for cigarettes, cigars, as well as loose change, keys or just as a decorative piece in your home, patio or cabin. This is a great patio ashtray.
  • HIGH QUALITY, SOLID, HEAVY DUTY PRODUCT - This antique ashtray for cigars looks and feels like a solid, good quality product, because it is. Made from recycled iron and finished with rust brown or silver color coating, this ashtray will not be damaged by cigarettes and cigars and will last you for generations.
  • 100% HAPPY CUSTOMERS: We're so confident that you'll love our product, that we'll give your hard-earned money back if you're not thrilled with your purchase. Simply contact our friendly customer service team to make it right. It's all on us - so there is zero risk to try the product today!

The Cast Iron Hand Antique Ashtray is a beautiful ashtray that is stylish and functional. This ashtray is a classic cast iron with an antique patina, it also has an authentic rough textured finish.

Key Features

  • Unique ashtray design
  • Masculine yet elegant
  • Cast iron with antique patina
  • Durable

A perfect gift for yourself or for the cigar smoker in your life. Ideal for fathers day, birthdays, anniversaries, a thank you or even a gift for your boss.

This vintage design suits every cigar, and is both masculine and elegant at the same time. Measurements are 8” x 4” x 2” height and due to the materials, it can withstand all weather conditions and frequent use.

This unique ashtray is well priced and has exceptional reviews to go with it. The only real negative of the Cast Iron Hand Antique Ashtray is that realistically it can only accommodate one cigar at a time.

2. Stinky Cigar Ashtray

Stinky Cigar Ashtray

$21.49  in stock
2 new from $19.99
Free shipping
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • 4 polished stainless steel stirrups, fingers designed to prevent cigars from tumbling off
  • Windproof with 3-Inch deep bowl and 8-inch diameter, heat resistant and easy to clean
  • Large capacity lets you smoke all night without emptying the ashtray
  • Perfect for your patio, lounge, living room, anywhere indoor and outdoor
  • Known as the Original Stinky Cigar Ashtray

Don’t be discouraged by the name, the Stinky Cigar Ashtray is a windproof stainless steel cigar ashtray that has a considerably large bowl to collect ash.

Key Features

  • Solid construction
  • Floats in water
  • Durable
  • Polished stainless steel
  • Windproof
  • 3-Inch Deep Bowl
  • 8-Inch Diameter

The original and very popular stinky cigar ashtray. This design has 4 fingers meaning you can rest four cigars on the ashtray.

With a considerably deep bowl at 3 inches as well as an 8-inch diameter, emptying this ashtray is less frequent than most. Another great feature of such a deep bowl is that it is windproof- cigar ash won’t be blown all over the area.

Featuring a polished stainless steel finish, the Stinky Cigar Ashtray is designed to last and is very easy to clean. A functional, attractive and simplistic design, it’s easy to see why this is a favorite.

3. Tobacco Leaf Print Crystal Cigar Ashtray

Tobacco Leaf Print Crystal Cigar Ashtray

$38.50  in stock
3 new from $38.50
Free shipping
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • 4 cigar ashtray
  • Made from clear K9 crystal
  • Tobacco leaf art applied to the base that reflects throughout this entire piece in 3D
  • Beautiful and decorative design with elegant look
  • Packed individually in a custom gift box

The Tobacco Leaf Print cigar ashtray is another unique ashtray design that is made from clear K9 crystal. It is a durable and solid piece that is subtle yet still enough to make a statement.

Key Features

  • Made from crystal
  • Tobacco leaf artwork
  • Elegant design
  • Holds 4 cigars

This ashtray comes in a very nice gift box as well. The tobacco leaf art is at the base of the ashtray and reflects throughout the crystal in 3D. It is a beautiful design that really suits the home, office or outdoor space.

The heaviness of this ashtray means it’s going to stay put. Although, if using it outdoors be mindful of the print wearing off from the bottom.

Due to the material composition, cleaning this ashtray is quick and easy to do. Measuring 6″ x 6″ and roughly 2″ high the Tobacco Leaf Print cigar ashtray will easily fit into your home.

4. Mantello Ceramic

Mantello Ceramic

$12.99  in stock
1 new from $12.99
Free shipping
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • Approx 8" X 4"
  • Blue Ceramic Design
  • Deep Wide Basin
  • Durable Ceramic
  • Holds Large cigar

Mantello are leaders in the cigar industry and the Deep Blue Ceramic Ashtray is a great choice for those wanting a single cigar ashtray. Also great for those who are traveling and need an ashtray for this.

Key Features

  • Holds one, large cigar
  • Blue Ceramic Design
  • Deep Wide Basin
  • Durable

This ashtray is thin and compact yet strong and durable. Measuring in at roughly 8″ x 4″ this ashtray will easily travel with you or make for an excellent choice for various points around your home or office where you smoke.

The blue ceramic design is classy, yet simplistic. Durable and designed to last this ceramic cigar ashtray will see you through.

With a deep basin for collecting the cigar ash, the Deep Blue Ceramic Ashtray will fit just one cigar. However, the single cigar space is suited for a large ring gauge.

5. Triangular Maple Lacquer

Triangular Maple Lacquer

 out of stock
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • Size: 7-1/2"L x 7-1/2"W x 1-1/4"H
  • Black Sides for Contrast
  • Color: Lacquered Dark Maple Wood
  • 3 Grooved Cigar Beds
  • Stainless Steel Ash Reservoir

The Triangular Maple Lacquer 3 Cigar Ashtray is a combination of dark Maple wood and black accents. Sophisticated and stylish, this ashtray will compliment your office or home perfectly.

Key Features

  • Stylish design
  • Laquered dark maple wood
  • 3 grooved cigar beds
  • Stainless steel ash reservoir

This ashtray has 3 grooved cigar beds and a fairly large basin that can easily be removed for cleaning purposes.  This piece will look good in your office, bar or pool room.

Solid and durable, this ashtray measures 7-1/2″L x 7-1/2″W x 1-1/4″H. Although not specified the cigar slots will accommodate cigars up to 54 ring gauge in size.

Fairly large, this ashtray feels and looks a lot more expensive than it really is. Overall the Triangular Maple Lacquer 3 Cigar Ashtray is an affordable and stylish ashtray, the perfect complement to a ‘gentleman’s room’.

6. Big Easy Square Grid Ashtray

Big Easy Square Grid

$45.00  in stock
3 new from $45.00
Free shipping
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • Handcrafted Polished Pewter
  • 7-Inch Square
  • Unique and Impressive Gift for Any Cigar Enthusiast
  • Special Grid Design for Ease of Use
  • Great for Outdoors

The Big Easy Square Grid ashtray is a statement piece. Handcrafted from polished pewter this ashtray is the perfect companion for outdoor cigar smokers.

Key Features

  • 7-inch square
  • Grid design for ease of use
  • Great for outdoors
  • Handcrafted

The notches on this ashtray are large enough to accommodate ring gauge 60 cigars. As there are grooves going both ways, the only issue will be playing Tetris to fit multiple cigars on.

Originating from India this product is solid and durable, weatherproof and very easy to clean. Due to the material used it is fire resistance as well.

With glowing customer reviews, the Big Easy Square Grid ashtray is a little more expensive than previous ashtrays but will last a lifetime!

7. Handmade Wooden Cigar Ashtray

Handmade Wooden Cigar Ashtray

$37.40
$22.47  in stock
1 new from $22.47
Free shipping
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • ✅ 100% Unique Handcrafted ashtrays | Each ashtray has its own carefully crafted shape and character.
  • ✅ Holds Cigars and Cigarettes | Each ashtray contains 3 handmade spaces to hold whatever you smoke.
  • ✅ 100% High Quality Teak Wood | Solid wooden ashtrays last a lifetime and never go out of style.
  • ✅ Not Just An Ashtray | The classic finish adds character to any room inside or outside your home.
  • ✅ 100% Hassle Free Money Back Guarantee | If for any reason you are unhappy simply send it back.

The Handmade Wooden Cigar Ashtray is a very unique design that is bound to make a statement in your preferred smoking area!

Key Features

  • Handcrafted
  • Space for 3 cigars 
  • Made from high-quality teak wood
  • Solid and durable

As these ashtrays are handcrafted, no two are the same, each offers its’ own individual characteristics. The idea behind this being that no two smokers’ experiences are the same, no two cigars should be the same.

Made from high-quality teak wood, this is a unique, wooden ashtray made from the most durable of hardwoods. Suited for indoors and outdoors as well as all weather conditions.

Versatile, durable and unique, the Handmade Wooden Cigar Ashtray is a one of a kind piece.

8. Boca Grande Maduro

Boca Grande Maduro

$30.00  in stock
1 new from $30.00
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • Maduro finish
  • Leaf shape and design
  • Can hold 2 cigars
  • Great for indoor or outdoor use
  • Silicone pads prevent furniture scratching

Another unique and striking ashtray, the Boca Grande is a simplistic yet stylish leaf design. With a double cigar rest at either end of the ashtray, this piece looks good indoors and outdoors.

Key Features

  • Maduro finish
  • Leaf shape and design
  • Holds 2 cigars
  • Suitable for indoor and outdoor use
  • Silicone pads prevent furniture scratching

Made from heavy resin, this is a weatherproof, durable design. Measurements are 11″1/2 x 6″1/2 x 2″1/4.

With silicone pads attached, this prevents the ashtray from scratching your furniture. Big and wide, this ashtray has plenty of space for collecting the ash of the two cigars it can accommodate.

Another great feature of this ashtray design is that the air can flow under and around the cigar which helps to keep it burning evenly.

The Boca Grande is a beautiful piece that will suit your smoking area nicely.

9. CiTree Cigar Ashtray

CiTree Cigar Ashtray

$13.99  in stock
1 new from $13.99
1 used from $13.48
Free shipping
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • Compact design with single cigar rest, deep ashtray reservoir for ashes. Works in any setting where smokers are accommodated.
  • Soft non-slip bottom design, avoid scratching the desktop, also avoid being blown away by wind.
  • Material: Made of solid Aluminum, so it's durable, heavy-duty, not easy to break, corrosion resistant and impact resistant.
  • Easy to clean by using a wet sponge or cloth. 30 days Money Back Guarantee.

The CiTree Cigar Ashtray is a very modern and sleek looking ashtray that holds one cigar at a time. This ashtray has a non-slip bottom to prevent it from slipping and scratching your desktop in the process.

Key Features

  • Stylish design
  • Non-slip bottom
  • Solid aluminum design
  • Corrosion-resistant
  • Easy to clean
  • Deep ash reservoir

Made from solid aluminum this ashtray is solid and resistant to corrosion. Durable and difficult to break this ashtray can be easily cleaned with a wet sponge or cloth.

Compact enough to travel with or place in various areas around your home, office or outdoor area. The reservoir is deep.

Available in silver or black, the CiTree Cigar Ashtray is stylish and sleek and comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee if you are unsure of your purchase.

10. Mantello Cigars Ashtray

Mantello Cigars Ashtray

$21.99  in stock
1 new from $21.99
Free shipping
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • Approx. Dimensions: 8.5" W x 8.5" L x 2.5" H. 4-Wide Cigar Rests
  • Made of Kiln Cured Lacquer Glazed Porcelain, Deep Onyx Black Finish
  • Perfect Accent Piece for any Indoor or Outdoor Table, Easily Wipes Clean
  • Deep Basin so Ashes Stay in Place, Heat Resistant you'll never have a Stains
  • Felt Bumpers on the Bottom so you don't to worry about Sliding and Scratches

The Mantello Cigars Large Black Cigar Ashtray is simplistic yet exudes class and style. This ashtray will look good just about anywhere.

Key Features

  • Made from porcelain
  • Onyx black finish
  • Easy to clean
  • Holds 4 cigars
  • Deep basin
  • Heat & stain resistant

This ashtray is made of kiln cured, lacquer glazed porcelain and has a very nice, onyx black finish. With four wide grooves, this ashtray can hold four cigars.

Measuring in an 8 1/2 inches long and 2 1/2 inch high this is a solid and sturdy design that will look good regardless of where you use it.

The basin of the Mantello Cigars Large Black Cigar Ashtray is deep meaning ashes will remain in place. There are also bumpers along the bottom of the ashtray to prevent it from moving around.

11. GALINER Cigar Ashtray

GALINER Cigar Ashtray

$25.00
$14.99  in stock
1 new from $14.99
Free shipping
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • COMPACT AND PORTABLE-----Single cigar rest and water drop shaped design for smoking convenience. A perfect cigar ashtray for a Desktop or Small Table and Fits Inside a Desk Drawer.
  • PREMIUM MATERIAL-----Solid aluminum material, anti-rust, anti-corrosion, anti-impact. This cigar ashtray is very durable that can be used for a long time.
  • NON-SLIP DESIGN-----The nonskid design under the bottom provided good stability, keeping contacting most of the table top and can't move. Avoid the table surface abrasions, scratches, effectively improve the cigar ashtray life.
  • MODELLING CONCISE-----This Cigar Ashtray was designed with all the rounded corners, do not hide waste, easy to clean.
  • WHAT YOU GET ----- GALINER Cigar Ashtray. Together with 30 Days Money Back.

The Galiner Cigar Ashtray is a portable design that can accommodate one cigar. The design is non-slip, stable and due to the bottom won’t stain or scratch the surface where it is used.

Key Features

  • Stylish and simplistic
  • Solid, aluminum material
  • Non-slip design
  • Easy to clean

Shaped like a water droplet, catching cigar ash is easy, but cleaning it is even easier. Small enough to fit into your desktop drawers or into your briefcase.

Made from high quality, solid aluminum this is an anti-rust, anti-corrosion and anti-impact ashtray that is durable and designed to last.

Available in yellow, black and silver the Galiner Cigar Ashtray is the ultimate travel companion. Lightweight yet sturdy, this design is durable and will see you through your business trips.

12. Limited Edition Arturo Fuente Porcelain Cigar Ashtray

Limited Edition Arturo Fuente Porcelain Cigar Ashtray

$57.00  in stock
5 new from $49.90
Free shipping
Buy on Amazon
Amazon.com
as of November 8, 2019 10:04 am

Features

  • Journey Through Time Ceramic Ashtray
  • Deep Center to hold ashes
  • 4 Huge Cigar Slots
  • Gold Accents

A popular ashtray the Arturo Fuente Porcelain Cigar Ashtray is manufactured by master cigarmakers Carlos Fuente Sr. and Carlos Fuente Jr.

Key Features

  • Limited edition piece
  • Deep center to hold ashes
  • 4 Huge Cigar Slots
  • Gold Accents

Featuring four huge cigar slots, this ashtray can accommodate even the fattest of cigars. The center of the ceramic ashtray is deep meaning it can hold a lot of ash.

This is a limited edition piece that is hugely popular amongst cigar aficionados. With nothing but glowing reviews, this ashtray can be used just about anywhere around the home, office or smoking den.

With ‘We Will Never Rush the Hands of Time’ written on the top. The  Limited Edition Large 8.75″ Arturo Fuente Porcelain Cigar Ashtray is a solid piece that evokes the history of cigars with each use.

What to Look For in a Cigar Ashtray

There are a few things you need to consider before making a cigar ashtray purchase. Although the design is what is going to catch your attention, the functionality is equally as important.

Materials & Construction

There are many different materials to choose from, metal, plastic, wood and the list goes on. The important thing is how sturdy and well made the ashtray is. You really don’t want to buy something that will fall to pieces with its first few uses.

Reliability & Functionality

The ashtray needs to do its job properly. Ideally, you don’t want cigar ash falling off the sides and creating a mess. It needs to hold your cigars and treat them with the respect their deserve.

Design

Being able to accommodate a wide variety of ring sizes is pretty important unless you only plan to smoke the same size cigar for the rest of your life. Generally, the cigar holder parts of the ashtray are very large but bear in mind the size with the smaller models available.

The design also shows the style or class you want to bring to your experience. Obviously this is an incredibly personal decision although there are a few best-sellers included in this review if you are looking to gift a cigar ashtray.

Value for Money

Cigar ashtrays come in a range of prices and generally are designed to last. Investing in a quality, well-made ashtray from day one will serve you well.

Bottom Line

Cigar ashtrays are an important accessory to add to your cigar collection. They make great gift ideas for the cigar aficionado in your life as well. There are countless designs and models on the market so finding one that is functional and suits your style is paramount.

You may also like

Leave a Comment