We may earn a small commission on purchases made through our links. Learn more.
When it comes to cigars, and most other things in life, you typically get what you pay for. Specifically, with cigars, there is a clear difference between a $10, $20, and even $50 cigar. But for most cigar smokers, shelling out $10+ every day for a cigar just isn’t feasible.
Instead, you have to look towards cheaper options that still have a similar quality and flavor to those expensive “top of the line” brands. That’s why in today’s article we are going to be taking a look at the best cigars under $5.
So if you are ready to save some dough while still getting a solid cigar smoking experience, you have come to the right place! Because in this article we have assembled 12 different cigars that represent the “best of the best” for cigars priced under $5 a stick.
Not only do these cigars offer an outstanding value, but they also have flavors and construction quality that rivals cigars twice the price! Now let’s jump into our review of the best cigars under $5 and find a cigar that makes both you and your wallet happy.
Best cigars under $5
Enjoy a classic Cuban flavor profile with the flawless Arturo Fuente Cuban cigar series.
Key Features
- Medium Bodied
- Cameroon Wrapper
- Dominican Filler
- Price: ~$5
Arturo Fuente is an extremely popular cigar brand thanks to its affordable lines of smooth smoking cigars. Perhaps the best series of them all is the Cuban line of cigars. Made to have a classic Cuban taste, these cigars feature a mix of flavors to create a medium-bodied smoke.
Most of the bolder flavor comes from a Cameroon Wrapper while the lighter flavors originate from premium Dominican long-filler.
Despite being a medium-bodied cigar, the Arturo Fuente Cuban smokes smooth and without too much of a punch, also very easy to light. Most vitolas are available between $4.50 and $5 a piece.
Pros
- Flawless Construction
- Widely Available
- Consistent Medium Bodied Flavor
Cons
- None
Arturo Fuente is a staple brand of cigars and the Cuban series is one of the best cigars you can get for under $5.
2. Alec Bradley Sun Grown
Alec Bradley keeps its cigars accessible to all with the economically priced Sun Grown series of cigars.
Key Features
- Full Bodied
- Mata Fina Wrapper
- Nicaraguan, Columbian, Honduran Filler
- Price: ~$4.50
Don’t think that cheap cigars can have the same abundant flavor as higher-priced offerings? Think again! With the Alec Bradley Sun Grown series, cigar smokers are presented with a multinational cigar that is chock full of complex flavors.
To create the base flavors for the cigar, Alec Bradley blends turned to a three-nation blend of Nicaraguan and Columbian long-fillers and a Honduran binder. To give the Sun Grown that last little kick of flavor, the blenders used a Brazillian Mata Fina Wrapper. At just $4.50 a cigar, this is by far one of the best full-bodied cigars under $5.
Pros
- Premium Aged Tobacco
- Expert Construction
- Abundant Flavor
- Great Value For A Full Bodied Cigar
Cons
- Could Be Too Strong For Some
If you are a lover of complex flavors and heavy smoke, then you have to give the Alec Bradley Sun Grown a try!
3. CAO Brazilia Gol!
Taste all the different exotic flavors that Brazillian tobacco has to offer with the CAO Brazilia Gol! series.
Key Features
- Full Bodied
- Arapiraca Maduro Wrapper
- Brazillian Filler
- Price: ~$4.75
Each and every nuanced flavor in a cigar comes from a certain type of tobacco grown in a number of areas. Cigar blenders then bring together all these different types of tobacco to create certain flavor profiles.
While most cigar smokers have become accustomed to tobacco blends from the Dominican Republic, Honduras, or Nicaragua, the boldest of flavors can be found in Brazil!
So with the Brazilia Gol!, CAO brought together an all Brazillian long-filler interior with a Brazillian Arapiraca Maduro Wrapper. The result is a dark and oily cigar that has a variety of complex and exotic flavors. Most CAO Brazilia Gol! cigars retail in the neighborhood of about $4.75 per stick.
Pros
- Premium Aged Tobacco
- Dark Oily Wrapper
- Exotic Flavors
Cons
- Could Be Too Strong For Some
Because of the bold flavors, the CAO Brazilia Gol! Might not be an everyday cigar, but it is certainly worth a try!
4. Drew Estate Nica Rustica
Drew Estate brings together a variety of bold flavors in a well-balanced smoke with the Nica Rustica line of cigars.
Key Features
- Full Bodied
- Connecticut Broadleaf Wrapper
- Nicaraguan Filler
- Price: ~$4.50
Drew Estate’s cigar lineups cover everything from uber expensive to low-cost everyday cigars. But if you want to shoot right down the middle, you’ll find the Nica Rustica line. Made with a set of well-balanced flavors, this cigar line is perfect for a full-flavored, low-cost smoke.
In this version, Drew Estate uses premium Nicaraguan long-filler wrapped in a Maduro Connecticut Broadleaf Wrapper. This combination brings together lots of spice and earthiness from the filler and a simple sweetness from the Maduro wrapper. At $4.50 a cigar, these are a steal of a deal!
Pros
- Premium Aged Tobacco
- Expert Construction
- Well Balanced Flavors
Cons
- Could Be Too Strong For Some
The Nica Rustica line of cigars has all the premium features of Drew Estate’s more prestigious brands at a price that just makes sense.
5. Rocky Patel American Selection
Made to please the American market, the Rocky Patel American Selection is a value-oriented mild smoke.
Key Features
- Mild Bodied
- Connecticut Shade Wrapper
- Nicaraguan & Honduran Filler
- Price: ~$4.00
Rocky Patel is a name known for high-quality cigars that have well-balanced flavors and flawless construction. Despite most Rocky Patel offerings appealing to the masses, Rocky went out and created a cigar solely for the American market. Dubbed the American Selection, this series of cigars has a lower price point and a milder flavor profile.
Each cigar in the American Selection is handcrafted and includes a mixed Nicaraguan and Honduran tobacco long-filler wrapped in a silky smooth Connecticut Shade Wrapper. The smoke is creamy and sweet with notes of cedar and hay. This cigar is certainly a must-try for those who love a mild and mellow smoke.
Pros
- Extra Aged Tobacco
- Flawless Wrapper
- Mellow Flavors
- Great Value
Cons
- None
Expert construction and a mix of relaxing flavors make the American Selection from Rocky Patel a great cigar that everyone should have in their humidor.
6. Punch Elites
The Punch brand of cigars is legendary among cigar lovers who love a flavorful and affordable cigar.
Key Features
- Full Bodied
- Sumatra Wrapper
- Honduran Filler
- Price: ~$3.00
For under $5 it’s hard to beat any of the Punch cigar offerings. Not only are the cigars flavorful, but they keep true to Honduran cigar heritage. If you are a new cigar smoker looking for a more flavorful smoke, Punch is the way to go!
To break down what makes up a Punch cigar, we have to start with the filler tobacco. Grown, picked, and cured in Honduras, the premium long-filler makes up the vibrant and robust flavors. Punch then finishes off the cigar with the Sumatra wrapper that brings in a bit more spice and boldness.
Another positive of Punch cigars are the wide variety of sizes and shapes, with most being around the $3 price range.
Pros
- Premium Tobacco
- Excellent Construction
- Bright Flavor Profile
- Great Value
Cons
- None
If you want to have a true Honduran cigar experience, there is truly nothing better than a Punch cigar.
7. Isla Del Sol
Isla Del Sol keeps its cigar’s flavor profile simple and inviting for any level of cigar smoker.
Key Features
- Mild Bodied
- Sumatra Wrapper
- Nicaraguan Filler
- Price: ~$4.00
Keeping with the island theme, Isla Del Sol’s cigars are all about having a relaxing smoke. So whether it is with your morning coffee or after dinner, the Isla Del Sol cigar is certainly a perfect match. This milder flavor profile also makes this a great cigar for beginners.
Simplicity is the name of the game with Isla Del Sol so it’s no surprise that the construction of these cigars is kept super simple. Each cigar solely consists of Nicaraguan long-filler and a seamless Sumatra Wrapper. Cigar aging does take place alongside coffee beans which impart a slight natural coffee flavor.
Pros
- Premium Tobacco
- Flawless Construction
- Natural Coffee Flavor
Cons
- None
Do yourself a favor and start relaxing with the pleasing flavors of Isla Del Sol cigar!
8. La Aurora Corojo
Released over 10 years ago, the La Aurora Corojo still holds up as a full-flavored medium-bodied smoke.
Key Features
- Medium Bodied
- Corojo Wrapper
- Dominican & Nicaraguan Filler
- Price: ~$7.00
This particular line of cigars from La Aurora has gained praise from a wide variety of cigar smokers for being flavorful without being too heavy. So it’s no wonder that these cigars have been in production for over a decade! And based on all the popularity, these cigars will continue to be made for at least another decade.
All the robust flavors found in the La Aurora Corojo come from a mix of Dominican and Nicaraguan long-filler. Brighter flavors are also introduced through the seamless Corojo wrapper. Smokers should look out for flavors of wood, nuts, and a bit of spice.
Pros
- Premium Tobaccos
- Sharp Burn
- Full Flavor Profile
Cons
- None
With a great mix of savory flavors and smooth smoke, the La Aurora Corojo is a true winner at under $5 a stick.
9. Acid Subculture
Pump up the flavors even more with the longer aging process found in the Acid Subculture line of cigars.
Key Features
- Medium Bodied
- San Andres Wrapper
- Nicaraguan Filler
- Price: ~$4.00
Acid cigars are a popular way for beginners to get their first taste of premium cigars. The unique infused flavors give Acid cigars a sweeter smoke than that of natural medium and full-bodied cigars. The Subculture line of cigars certainly brings even more of Acid’s unique flavors thanks to its longer aging process.
Like a majority of Acid cigars, the Subculture line gets an all Nicaraguan long-filler. But the slight difference comes in the form of a San Andres Wrapper. These cigars are priced reasonably at $4 a stick considering they have had extra aging time.
Pros
- Extra Aged Tobacco
- Infused Flavors
- Exotic Flavor Profile
Cons
- None
If you are a fan of Acid’s original lineup of cigars, then you have to give the more flavorful Subculture a try.
10. Gispert
Perhaps not the most known name in the cigar world, Gispert puts together a well-balanced flavor profile in its namesake cigar.
Key Features
- Medium Bodied
- Connecticut Shade Wrapper
- Honduran & Nicaraguan Filler
- Price: ~$4.50
Perhaps the best thing about the cigar world is that there are so many smaller “boutique” style of brands. Offering their own signature flavors, these smaller brands tend to create memorable cigars. In the case of Gispert, the cigar is full of easy to discern flavors that make it an enjoyable smoke.
Each Gispert cigar is handcrafted using a mixed Honduran and Nicaraguan long-filler and a golden Connecticut Shade Wrapper. The flavor profile is a mix of earthy hay, hints of spice, and a subtle sweetness. Gispert certainly brings its own well-balanced flavor to the mix with this line of cigars.
Pros
- Seamless Construction
- Great Burn
- Creamy & Flavorful
Cons
- None
Dive into the world of boutique cigars on the cheap with the smooth smoking Gispert cigar.
11. Don Thomas S.E. Connecticut
Relax your day away with a mellow tasting Don Thomas Special Edition Connecticut cigar.
Key Features
- Mild Bodied
- Connecticut Shade Wrapper
- Honduran, Dominican & Nicaraguan Filler
- Price: ~$4.00
It almost seems that mild cigars are a dime a dozen. But the way Don Thomas has crafted its Special Edition Connecticut series, shows that mild cigars can be tasteful and smooth in all the right ways. So whether you are new to cigars or an aficionado, this cigar is a must-try!
Each Special Edition Connecticut starts with a three-nation blend of long-fillers and binders. All these mild flavors then get wrapped in a silky smooth Connecticut Shade Wrapper. All this results in a well-constructed mild smoke that goes great with a cup of coffee.
Pros
- Premium Tobacco
- Silky Smooth Smoke
- Mild Flavor Profile
Cons
- None
Nothing under $5 beats the smooth mellow flavors found in the Don Thomas Special Edition Connecticut.
12. Carlos Torano Signature
Perhaps the most robust of the Torano family’s brands, the Carlos Torano Signature series is a true masterpiece.
Key Features
- Full Bodied
- Arapiraca Maduro Wrapper
- Nicaraguan Filler
- Price: ~$3.50
As with any signature series, if you are willing to sign your own name to the product it better be pretty darn good. Carlos Torano certainly abides by this theory since the Signature series cigars are absolute winners. Robust flavors and top tier construction results in a consistent and pleasurable smoke.
Getting the Carlos Torano Signature series cigar’s blend just right took some time. But the Nicaraguan long-filler wrapper in a Brazillian Arapiraca Maduro Wrapper is a robust and exotic show of flavor. What’s even more impressive? These cigars cost just $3.50 a piece for most sizes.
Pros
- Super Aged Tobacco
- Perfect Construction
- Robust Flavor Profile
- Outstanding Value
Cons
- Very Spicy Taste
Certainly worthy of a spot in your humidor, the Carlos Torano Signature series is a great bang for the buck cigar.
Bottom Line
We hope that this article has shed some light on some of the best cigars you can get at under $5 a stick. None of the cigars featured on this list are considered “cheap” and can even give higher-priced cigars a run for their money. Consistent construction, draw, and burn are traits that every one of these twelve cigars exhibits.
Hopefully, this article has also made it pretty clear you don’t have to break the bank to have a quality cigar. Some of the greatest value can be found in cigars like CAO Brazilia Gol!, Rocky Patel Sun Grown, and Carlos Torano Signature series.
Each of these cigars has exotic blends of tobacco that provide flavors normally found on much more expensive cigar lines. So if you want to experience new flavors on the cheap, then you gotta give these cigars a try!
Overall, we feel that these cigars make up the bulk of the best cigars priced below $5. So the next time you are looking to fill your humidor, turn to these outstanding cigars!
Check out the Cigar Cigar homepage for more expert reviews and guides.
Best Mild Cigars
Dan Stevenson
I have been smoking cigars for 30 years and counting, I started at 18 years old with mild Cubans and worked my way up to medium and now bold. I own 4 humidors, that I try to keep stocked at all times.
