fbpx
CigarCigar Info is a community-supported website. We may earn a small commission on purchases made through our links. Learn more.

Best Mild Cigars

by CigarCigar
male holding a mild cigar

Nothing beats a good cigar, but some people prefer milder varieties that don’t have quite as much of an effect. They typically have woodsy or earthy tones that might have complex hints of other flavor profiles like leather or nuts.

Because they’re so easy to smoke, the best mild cigars are often a favorite for beginners or for sharing with other people who may not have a particularly developed cigar palette. They’re good for those new to cigar smoking because they are easier to enjoy, resulting in less sputtering or coughing from the smoker.

In this guide, we’ll go over the best mild cigars around. All of them come in packs ranging from 5 to 50 and some of them are even sample packs including multiple cigar brands. These are ideal if you want to try out lots of different cigars over time. Let’s get started.

Top-Rated Mild Cigars

Like Rocky Patel’s other vintage collection of cigars, the Vintage Connecticut 1999 boasts a blend of premium flavors.

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Honduras Filler
  • Price: ~$10

Full-bodied bold cigars are where Rocky Patel’s made a name for itself. But to cater to the fans of mild cigars, Rocky Patel created the Vintage Connecticut 1999 line. To put it simply; these cigars are a silky smooth smoke full of decadent mellow flavors.

To create these works of art, Rocky Patel uses a mix of a Honduran binder and long filler wrapped in a silky smooth Connecticut Shade Wrapper. Both the filler and wrapper are aged for a total of 7+ years to make sure that all the flavors come through without even a hint of harshness.

With retail prices around $10 a stick, the Vintage Connecticut 1999 is certainly worth the cost.

Pros

  • 7+ Year Aged Tobacco
  • Outstanding Construction
  • Well Balanced Mellow & Nutty Smoke

Cons

  • Slightly Expensive

Many higher-priced cigars can’t even come close to the delicate and consistent flavors found in the Rocky Patel Vintage Connecticut 1999, making it a great buy.

2. Macanudo Gold 

Get the smoothest and mellowest smoke available in the Macanudo lineup with the Gold Label series.

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Dominican Republic Filler
  • Price: ~$7.50

If you are someone who likes an easy smoking cigar with simple flavors and smooth draw, then you are in for a treat! Macanudo’s Gold Label series of cigars features the mildest and smoothest flavors possible. So just kick back, relax, and enjoy the simple flavors of mild tobacco, hay, and toast.

For flavors this smooth, Macanudo went with a premium cured Connecticut Shade Wrapper and an all Dominican Republic long-filler. This combination is similar to that found in Macanudo’s Cafe lineup of cigars.

And at $7.50 a cigar, it’s a bit more expensive. But the flavors truly can not be beaten!

 Pros

  • Premium Aged Tobacco
  • Specialty Cured Wrapper
  • Smoother Smoke Than Other Macanudo Offerings

Cons

  • None

No matter if you are a beginner or seasoned vet, the Macanudo Gold Label is an excellent choice for a mild cigar.

 3. Griffin’s #300

Made in the same factory as the prestigious Davidoff cigars, the Griffin #300 series cigars are a sumptuously mild delight.

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Dominican Republic Filler
  • Price: ~$7.00

Griffin scores points across the board not only for its mild light flavors but also for its flawless construction and smooth draw. Of course, the flavor is consistent throughout the whole smoke thanks to expert blending at the Davidoff cigar factory. This makes the Griffin #300 a great on-the-go or social style of cigar.

The handcrafted construction of the Griffin #300 starts with premium aged Dominican long-filler and binder. All this goodness is wrapped up in a silky Connecticut Shade Wrapper. The end result is a smooth smoke with hints of nuts and cedar. An exceptional cigar for a price of about $7 a stick.

 Pros

  • Flawless Construction
  • Premium Aged Tobacco
  • Hints of Nuts & Cedar

Cons

  • None

If you want a Davidoff experience without the Davidoff price, then you have to go with the Griffin #300 series.

 4. Oliva 

Add some new flavors to your mild body smoke with the Oliva Connecticut Reserve.

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Nicaraguan Filler
  • Price: ~$7.50

Oliva has a wide range of cigars that cover everything from mild to bold. But if you want a mild cigar with a bit more flavor, Oliva has you covered with the Oliva Connecticut Reserve. Rich and smooth, this cigar is a real treat!

Just like other mild cigars, Oliva uses a Connecticut Shade Wrapper. But to give the cigar a bit more body, the long-filler tobacco is a blend of aged Nicaraguan tobaccos. So apart from the mild flavors of cedar and toast, bolder flavors like pepper and coffee come through at the finish of each draw.

Toro sized versions of the Connecticut Reserve are a popular choice and can be had at $7.50 per cigar.

 Pros

  • Great Construction
  • Razor Sharp Burn
  • Mild With Some Bolder Flavors

Cons

  • None

Oliva really does a great job at balancing the mild and slightly bold flavors in the Connecticut Reserve series.

 5. AVO Classic No. 2

Blended specifically for famed pianist Avo Uvezian, the AVO Classic No. 2 is a must smoke cigar.

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Dominican Republic Filler
  • Price: ~$10

Zino Davidoff is a famed cigar blender for many of the best cigars in the Davidoff lineup. It’s no coincidence that Zino was the one to come up with the hit that is the AVO Classic No. 2. Not only does this cigar appeal to aficionados, but is a great smoke for beginners as well.

Overall construction is top-notch as one would expect from a Davidoff creation. A mix of five different Dominican long-fillers are wrapped under a dark Connecticut Shade Wrapper. Despite the darker look, the Classic No. 2 is still a mild and mellow smoke.

At $10 a stick, it is a bit more expensive than other cigars on our list but is certainly well worth the price.

 Pros

  • Five Tobacco Blend
  • Excellent Construction
  • Mild With Well Balanced Flavors

Cons

  • Slightly Expensive

Sit back and relax while taking in the delightfully mild flavors of the AVO Classic No. 2 series.

 6. Macanudo Cafe

Macanudo’s Cafe line of cigars is by far its most popular thanks to its smooth flavors and wide availability.

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Dominican Republic Filler
  • Price: ~$7

While the Macanudo Cafe line of cigars are not as mellow as the Gold Label series, they are still an outstanding choice for a mild cigar. They are even one of our top picks for cigar beginners that are looking for a quality smoke. But how does Macanudo create these coveted cigars?

First, they start with Dominican long-filler and a Connecticut Shade Wrapper. Both of these double aged tobaccos are then combined by an expert cigar roller to create the Cafe cigar we all love. At about $7 a cigar, these are some great mild cigars to always have on hand.

 Pros

  • Premium Construction
  • Double-Aged Tobacco
  • Mild & Creamy Flavors

Cons

  • None

If you want to keep your cigar budget a bit lower but still keep the Macanudo taste, opt for the Cafe over the Gold Label.

 7. EP Carrillo 

Start smoking some of EP’s newest line of mild cigars, the Carrillo New Wave Connecticut!

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Nicaraguan & Dominican Republic Filler
  • Price: ~$6.50

Mild cigar smokers can rejoice over the ability to get an E.P. blended cigar at a price that is just right! In the Carrillo New Wave Connecticut series of cigars, smokers are treated to a mix of bright mellow flavors as well as some toned down spice.

It also shouldn’t be a surprise that each cigar burns true with flavor consistency only known to E.P.C. Getting the perfect blend of flavors requires the perfect mix of both Nicaraguan and Dominican long-fillers. To add that creamy and smooth element, a flawless Connecticut Shade Wrapper is used.

Priced near $6.50 a stick, the New Wave Connecticut is definitely worthy of a spot in your cigar rotation.

 Pros

  • Premium Tobacco
  • Outstanding Construction
  • Mild Flavors With Slight Spice

Cons

  • None

Despite being the cheapest option from E.P., the Carrillo New Wave Connecticut is full of well-balanced flavors.

 8. Romeo Y Julieta 1875

Romeo Y Julieta invites you to fire up a tradition in cigars, the 1875 series.

 Key Features

  • Mild to Medium Bodied
  • Sumatra Wrapper
  • Dominican Republic Filler
  • Price: ~$5

Creating a line of cigars that stand the test of time is a testament to the quality of a cigar company’s blending and manufacturing process. Since its launch in 1875, Romeo Y Julieta has won various awards and undergone some changes.

But series like 1875 is what keeps cigar smokers coming back to Romeo Y Julieta. The construction of 1875 is a bit different than many other options in the mild category. While a common blend of Dominican long-fillers are present, Romeo Y Julieta opts for a slightly bolder Sumatra Wrapper.

This wrapper does give the cigar a few more notes of spice, it is still smooth and full of mild flavors.

 Pros

  • Choice Premium Tobacco
  • Great Construction
  • Mild Flavors With Slight Spice

Cons

  • A Little Heavier Than Some Other Options

Thousands of cigar smokers have fallen in love with the Romeo Y Julieta 1875 line of cigars, and you should too!

 9. CAO Gold

Strike gold every time you light up a CAO Gold series cigar!

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Nicaraguan Filler
  • Price: ~$5

CAO is one of the first premium brands beginner cigar smokers turn to when they need a well crafted and value-oriented smoke. In the case of the Gold series, CAO leaves behind its bold international flavors and instead goes with a milder blend of filler tobacco.

This gives a much more relaxing smoke that appeals to a wide variety of cigar smokers. Each Gold series cigar is handcrafted by expert rollers that combine Nicaraguan long-fillers with a silky Connecticut Shade Wrapper.

The result is a consistently smooth smoke with lots of light flavors. Plus, at just $5 a stick, this one won’t break the bank!

 Pros

  • Premium Tobacco
  • Great For Beginners
  • Mild & Smooth Flavors
  • Great Value

Cons

  • None

Recommended for beginners, the CAO Gold series gives cigar smokers a premium mild smoke at a great value.

 10. Baccarat

Go home a winner no matter what with the pleasing taste of Baccarat cigars.

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Honduran Filler
  • Price: ~$3.50

Cigar smokers know that Baccarat isn’t just a card game. It’s also a great tasting mild cigar that has a price that is just right. Plus, you can find Baccarat cigars in a wide range of sizes at many retail cigar outlets.

The construction of each cigar is surprisingly good considering the price and includes Honduran long-filler and a Connecticut Shade Wrapper. Baccarat does apply a “Sweet Cap” that makes this mild smoke even more pleasing. At $3.50 a stick, this cigar can be an inexpensive everyday treat!

 Pros

  • Great For Beginners
  • Mild & Smooth Flavors
  • Great Value

Cons

  • None

Mild, sweet, and at just the right price, the Baccarat cigar series are definitely worth a spot in your humidor.

 11. Don Diego

Don Diego is a brand to turn to for a light smoke at a price that doesn’t break the bank.

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Dominican & Brazillian Filler
  • Price: ~$3.75

While Don Diego isn’t a top tier brand in the cigar world, it plays an important role in bridging the gap between those top brands and some lower-end offerings. Cigar smokers can expect a relatively consistent level of quality and flavor similar to that of much more costly cigars.

These cigars are perfect for those looking to take a step up from the really cheap cigars. Made of a mix of Dominican and Brazillian long-filler, the Don Diego cigar has a mild flavor with a delightfully smelling aroma. Smoothness and a bit of sweetness come from a premium Connecticut Shade Wrapper.

While some construction issues have been reported, it’s nothing that is too concerning considering these cigars retail for a cheap $3.75 a piece.

 Pros

  • Smooth Draw & Flavors
  • Consistent Construction
  • Great Value

Cons

  • Some Could Have A Tight Draw

Come for the low price and stay for the mild creamy flavors with the Don Diego line of cigars.

 12. Don Thomas 

Don Thomas keeps a time-honored classic taste with its Special Edition line of cigars.

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Honduran Filler
  • Price: ~$3.75

Cigar manufacturers have been chasing new and bold flavors for the past few decades. But sometimes the best flavors and blends are those that have been loved for close to 100 years. Don Thomas puts these classic flavors into play with its newest Special Edition cigars.

Created with a unique three-nation blend of filler tobacco, the Special Edition cigar boasts toasty and nutty flavors. A bit of sweetness comes from premium Connecticut Shade Wrappers. This cigar definitely swings above its weight class in terms of value.

 Pros

  • Toast & Nutty Flavors
  • Great Construction
  • Great Value

Cons

  • None

It’s hard to beat the value proposition brought to the table by the Don Thomas Special Edition Cigar.

 13. Creme de Jamaica

Start your morning off right with a cup of coffee and a Creme de Jamaica cigar!

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Dominican & Indonesian Filler
  • Price: ~$3.50

Described as “extra mild”, these Creme de Jamaica cigars are certainly a mellow and relaxing smoke. Paired with a cup of coffee, these cigars get a whole new meaning of flavor. Add in the fact that the price tag of each cigar is about $3.50, and you got yourself a low cost, stress-reducing morning ritual.

To create such a mellow bodied cigar, Creme de Jamaica uses a unique blend of Dominican long-filler wrapper in an Indonesian binder. Then, to top it off, a silky Connecticut shade wrapper is applied. For the price, this is a hard cigar to beat!

 Pros

  • Light & Mild
  • Consistent Construction
  • Great Value

Cons

  • Burn Can Be Hit Or Miss

Smooth, light, and full of satisfying flavors, the Creme de Jamaica is an outstanding budget cigar.

 14. La Vieja Habana 

This is where the famous Drew Estate began, with the La Vieja Connecticut Shade.

 Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Nicaraguan Filler
  • Price: ~$4

You’d think the first cigar by one of the top brands in the cigar world back in 1994 would be the best of the best right? We’ll for most Drew Estate lovers it might not be the best, but it certainly is iconic! In fact, the La Vieja Habana Connecticut Shade is still one of Drew Estate’s best selling cigars.

Unlike most premium cigars, the La Vieja Habana Connecticut Shade uses a Nicaraguan filler that comes in a “Cuban Sandwich” style of long and short filler. All this is wrapped in a flawless Connecticut Shade Wrapper. At $4 a piece, these are some great burning and mild-tasting cigars.

 Pros

  • Made by Drew Estate
  • Excellent Burn & Construction
  • Earthy Mild Flavor

Cons

  • Cuban Sandwich Filler

Every cigar smoker should experience the La Vieja Habana Connecticut Shade to pay homage to the beginning of a true cigar empire.

 15. Quorum Shade

Save your money and get yourself some great tasting cigars when you choose Quorum Shade.

Key Features

  • Mild Bodied
  • Connecticut Shade Wrapper
  • Nicaraguan Filler
  • Price: ~$2

Now it should be stated right off the start that these cigars are considered budget cigars. More than likely these Quorum Shade cigars are “factory seconds” which were made for a better line of cigars but just didn’t meet the high-quality control standards.

So you should expect some minor issues like suboptimal burn quality or though draws. As for construction, the Quorum Shade are made using Nicaraguan long-filler wrapped in a Connecticut Shade Wrapper. Flavors like hay, toast, and some nuttiness are the easiest to discern. Overall, these cigars are some great value smokes.

Pros

  • Premium Tobacco
  • Earthy & Sweet Flavor
  • Low Cost

Cons

  • Hit Or Miss Build Quality
  • Some Are Over Packed

Despite the occasional dud, these Quorum Shade cigars are certainly worth the $2 price tag.

Bottom Line

All in all, the best mild cigars for your palette will depend on your smoking experience and the kinds of flavors you prefer in your cigar smoking sessions. You should also pay attention to the shape of the cigars and their leaf wrappings, as these can add different aesthetic benefits you might appreciate when sharing cigars with others or smoking by yourself.

It’s also a good idea to consider the sample packs if you’re new to cigar smoking in general. They’re one of the best ways you can determine what kinds of cigars you like and may even help you pick out new cigars in the future without having to break the bank.

Thanks for reading! For more Cigar reviews & accessories head over to our homepage. 

You may also like